Showing 1–24 of 542 results

• 
  Fudge

  1.5 pound Pick Your Own Fudge

  $16.95 Select options
• 
  Fudge

  1/2 Pound Fudge – Assorted – Pick Your Own

  $8.50 Select options
• 
  Easter

  2 Easter Pretzel Rods

  $3.99 Add to cart
• 
  Easter

  Baseball Bunny – solid

  $9.00 Add to cart
• 
  Easter

  Big Bunny Face Lollipop

  $5.99 Select options
• Out of stock
  Easter

  Carrot Cake Fudge

  $8.50 – $16.50 Select options
• 
  All Products with Chocolate

  Cheerleader

  $25.95 Add to cart
• 
  Candy Bars

  Class of 2020 Ridgewood Candy Bar

  $3.99 Add to cart
• 
  Candy Bars

  Class of 2020 Wayne Hills Candy Bar

  $3.99 Add to cart
• 
  Candy Bars

  Class of 2020 Wayne Valley Candy Bar

  $3.99 Add to cart
• 
  Candy Bars

  Congrats Graduate – Mortar Board Candy Bar

  $2.99 Select options
• 
  All Products with Chocolate

  Dolphin

  $17.50 Add to cart
• 
  Candy Bars

  Eastern Christian

  $3.99 Add to cart
• 
  All Products with Chocolate

  Graham Crackers

  $12.50 Select options
• 
  Candy Bars

  Happy Fathers Day

  $2.99 Select options
• 
  Every Day Molds

  High Heel Shoe

  $19.99 Add to cart
• 
  Candy Bars

  Indian Hills Candy Bar

  $3.99 Add to cart
• 
  Candy Bars

  Mahwah Class of Candy Bar

  $3.99 Add to cart
• 
  Candy Bars

  Northern Highlands Candy Bar

  $3.99 Add to cart
• 
  Holiday

  Passover Marzipan

  $11.99 Add to cart
• 
  All Products with Chocolate

  Peanut Butter Pals

  $12.50 – $24.95 Select options
• 
  All Products with Chocolate

  Piggy Bank

  $17.50 Add to cart
• 
  Candy Bars

  Ramapo Candy Bar

  $3.99 Select options
• 
  Candy Bars

  Ramsey High Class of Candy Bar

  $3.99 Add to cart